14 030
ediciones
Diferencia entre revisiones de «Discusión:El archivo de las tormentas»
→Cleaning up the Infobox: My reactions
(→Cleaning up the Infobox: My reactions) |
|||
|
:::While I agree it looks slightly cramped on mobile, I don't think it looks ''bad'' on mobile, and it doesn't impact usability. And is it really our goal to optimize for mobile anyway? I don't think that moving the keteks to the individual book pages and ketek page (although I agree they should also exist there) fulfills the same purpose of being able to view the similar structure for each Stormlight book. While I could get behind copying the table to provide a simple overview table on one page and a more detailed table on another page, I don't have permissions to create pages, so unless someone else wants to create that, I think this page is the place to include the detailed information. Speaking of creating pages, it would also be cool if someone uploaded the file https://www.brandonsanderson.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/WoR_EPHEMERA-KETEK_v02_fmt.jpeg as File:WoR_Endnote.jpg since File:Navani%27s_Ketek_glyphs.svg just isn't the same.
::::More people view the Coppermind on mobile than desktop, so I'm inclined to agree with Grace there. It definitely is something to worry about. We will eventually have a more mobile-centric skin. I can give you editor right so you can upload that file. -- 01:30, 12 July 2020 (UTC)
Alright, my general thoughts:
* Yes, the majority of our viewers are on mobile; "optimize" might be a bit strong, but it is something we want to be very conscientious of
* I agree, the table looks too cramped on mobile, and it feels to busy to me even on my laptop
* I still think people would want to see novellas and novels together; that's also consistent with what we do on [[Mistborn (series)]]
* Looking back, "expectation management" was bad wording on my part. You're right that Brandon has said he wants to write novellas about Lunamor and Lopen. He's also said he wants to write ''The Silence Divine'', a Silverlight novella, a ''Sixth of the Dusk'' sequel novella, a series of novellas starting with ''Adamant'', a Hoid's apprentice/magic kites novella... and I'm probably missing some. My point is, I'm not sure the Lunamor or Lopen novellas are at a stage where they need this kind of prominence.
On to specifics:
* First, I want to say I like how you did the in-world text links and years on the table (though I'd argue the years aren't really necessary for the prologue or interludes)
* I'd cut the ketek columns, for the reasons expressed above. Personally, I wouldn't have added the Prologue Viewpoint column, but I'm not opposed to it staying. I'm on the fence about the Interlude Viewpoint column, but I'd lean against it. It isn't clear at-a-glance what it means (are ''all'' interludes from ''The Way of Kings'' from Szeth's viewpoint?) and I don't see that character's identity as very important to the structure.
* I still think there should be one table, rather than a separate one for novellas, but I'd like to here the opinions of other Keepers (on everything else too, but this in particular). I'd also bring back the Length column with that; we could make it so that people could use that to separate novels from novellas, if they want.
* I could accept listing ''Horneater'', though even that's pushing it for me. The Lopen novella, however, seems way too indefinite to me to be on the table at this point.
I don't really like making changes to the page itself while things are under discussion, so I did some drafting in my user space (see [[User:Stargazer/General_Testing]]). Opinions welcome, including that I'm just crazy.
<br />--[[User:Stargazer|Stargazer]] ([[User talk:Stargazer|talk]]) 02:55, 12 July 2020 (UTC)
| |||