Diferencia entre revisiones de «Discusión:Rira»

← Edición anterior

Discusión:Rira (ver código)

Revisión del 02:20 18 ago 2013

1306 bytes añadidos , hace 10 años

→‎Name conflict

Chaos2651

Shards, Editors, Keepers, Synod

11 554

ediciones

Revisión del 16:24 17 ago 2013 (ver código) WeiryWriter (discusión \| contribs.) m ← Edición anterior		Revisión actual del 02:20 18 ago 2013 (ver código) Chaos2651 (discusión \| contribs.) (→‎Name conflict)
(No se muestran 4 ediciones intermedias de 3 usuarios)
== Name conflict == There is a character in [[Warbreaker]] with the name Rira ([[Thame]]'s boss, chapters 22, 31), and currently this country on Roshar. How shall we disambig? I'm thinking [[Rira (Roshar)]] and [[Rira (Nalthis)]] or [[Rira (Warbreaker)]] or [[Rira (character)]] vs [[Rira (country)]]. Will one get preference? (I'm siding towards the character, since they actually appear in the story) --[[User:Fbstj\|Joe ST]] ([[User talk:Fbstj\|talk]]) 13:38, 17 August 2013 (UTC) : I would have the preference for [[Rira (character)]] and [[Rira (country)]]. At this point, if one get's preference it should be the character I think.--[[User:WeiryWriter\|WeiryWriter]] ([[User talk:WeiryWriter\|talk]]) 16:12, 17 August 2013 (UTC) :: I don't understand what you mean by preference. I'm thinking we make one article Rira (character) and one Rira (country). Then we take the main Rira page and make it a disambiguation. Neither one needs any sort of preference. Unless anyone has any objections, as soon as I finish this article I'm now writing on Rira the man I'm going to make this change --[[User:Windrunner\|Windrunner]] ([[User talk:Windrunner\|talk]]) 18:18, 17 August 2013 (UTC) ::: We should go with country/character. I think Rira itself should redirect to what is likely to be searched more, which will definitely be the country. You don't want the main page to be a disambiguation; didn't we do that on Elantris and it went terribly? Still we can have a disambiguation and a notice on the top I guess. -- [[User:Chaos2651\|Chaos2651]] ([[User talk:Chaos2651\|talk]]) 19:07, 17 August 2013 (UTC) Why is [[Rira (country)]] more likely? I agree with the redirect, but do we really need to move the one that's getting the redirect? --[[User:Fbstj\|Joe ST]] ([[User talk:Fbstj\|talk]]) 19:26, 17 August 2013 (UTC) :Because a country in a ten book series will probably have more references to it eventually than a random side character from a single book? -- [[User:Chaos2651\|Chaos2651]] ([[User talk:Chaos2651\|talk]]) 02:20, 18 August 2013 (UTC)