40 275
ediciones
Diferencia entre revisiones de «Usuario discusión:Fbstj»
m
→Gas Giants of the Greater Roshar: +reply
m (→Gas Giants of the Greater Roshar: +reply) |
|||
|
So, your latest edit in [[Greater Roshar]] removed the individual list entries of the ten gas giants. I know that the Rosharan gas giants are boring and that their names are basically just numbers from one to ten, so I understand the urge to summarize them into a single sentence the way you did, but I believe it is more encyclopedic to name ''all'' the planets of the system in the article, not just the noteworthy ones. (There's also the personal reason that I spent time tediously forming that section so I prefer it not to be radically abridged, but that's a minor point.) [[User:Skaa|Skaa]] ([[User talk:Skaa|talk]]) 10:33, 30 November 2016 (MST)
: I'd prefer if it were maybe less abridged, by stating that they're named after the Vorin numbers (at least they're named that in the context of the star chart) but having ten lines of <code>;name: this is another gas giant named after a herald</code> isn't useful and actually distracts from the information 'there are ten gas giants on distant orbits' and doesn't really leave space for the stuff about them being far away and whatever that WoB about them is. that's my arguments/opinion anyway --[[User:Fbstj|Joe ST]] ([[User talk:Fbstj|talk]]) 12:26, 30 November 2016 (MST)
| |||